Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils, who doesn’t love that idea. However, this often comes with a hidden fear, “Will it irritate my eyes?” Many people love the look of an eyeliner pencil and how it instantly brightens up their face and adds a glistening luminosity to their eyes. But our eyes, eyelids and the skin under the eyes, all of these gang members are super delicate and soft on the inside. They need special care and you also need to be super cautious with what you are applying around your eyes.

Finish Type: Matte | Special Feature: Smudge Resistant, Waterproof | Material Type Free: Alcohol Free | Coverage: Full | Colors: 2 | Weight: 0.28g

Making it top on the list of best waterproof eyeliner pencils, we have Maybelline with its revolutionary New York Kohl Gel. With this one, all you have to do is line and blend and it does the magic for you. This eyeliner pencil works miraculously for all the smokey eye looks you want to nail. The super gentle and nourishing formula is blendable and buildable so you can decide your look for the day and vibe on it. It is dual-ended, featuring a gel tip and a precision blender tip that allows you to showcase your versatility with a smudge proof, waterproof and long-lasting color.

What do other eye makeup lovers have to say about it?
Love the smooth application and the dark pigment. It really stays on your eyes for a very long time. The quality is really amazing and long-lasting. It is suitable for those with sensitive eyes as it doesn’t cause any irritation or itching and comes off easily too without having to rub your eyes off.

Why does this waterproof eyeliner pencil deserve to be in your makeup vanity?

• Offers a smoldering tattoo matte finish for intense looks
• Comes with a dual-ended mechanical feature
• Features a built-in sharpener
• Suitable for contact lens wearers too

Pros

• Smudge-resistant
• 36 hour long-wear
• Glides easily

Cons

• May not be smudge proof when applied on waterline

2. Best in Application: Blue Heaven Intense Eyeliner Easy Sketch, Black

Item Form: Pencil | Finish Type: Matte | Special Feature: Waterproof, Fade Proof, Travel Size, Smudge Resistant | Product Benefits: Waterproof | Coverage: Full

Don’t let water or sensitivity come in the way of your gorgeous eye looks - this one by Swiss Beauty has got your back (and your eyes) like nothing else. It is completely waterproof, fade proof and smudge resistant. And don’t you worry because it takes care of your sensitive eyes too! It offers full coverage so you keep looking outstanding throughout the day.

What do other eye makeup lovers have to say about it?
The ease of use is outstandingly good. It leaves a great color on the eyelids and also lasts super long! This eyeliner pencil is also best for beginners as it causes zero irritation and itching in the eyes and actually delivers on the smudge-proof benefit.

Why does this waterproof eyeliner pencil deserve to be in your makeup vanity?

• Offers intense black color that’s completely water and smudge proof
• Stays up to 24 hours, adorning your eyes like nothing else
• Felt brush is super easy to use and glides smoothly

Pros

• Waterproof
• Smudge Proof
• Long-lasting

Cons

• May cause some dryness

3. Best in Stylish: LAKMÉ Eyeconic Black Kajal, Matte Kohl Liner In A Twist Up Pencil

Item Form: Pencil | Finish Type: Matte | Special Feature: Waterproof, Transfer Proof, Smudge Resistant | Product Benefits: Long Lasting | Material Type Free: Paraben Free | Coverage: Full | Skin Type: All

Keep the nasties behind as you get ready for a day of serving looks! This eyeliner pencil is free from any parabens and sulfates and offers a deep black color that lasts for 24 hours. It is also ophthalmologically tested to suit even the most sensitive eyes. The coverage is full and pigmentation is supreme to give you the oh-so-dark look you have been longing for!

What do other eye makeup lovers have to say about it?
The texture is smooth as butter and it glides so easily. It is super easy to apply, is durable, the color is supreme and the quality is also awesome! It actually does stay on the eyes for a very long period of time - almost the entire day!

Why does this waterproof eyeliner pencil deserve to be in your makeup vanity?

• Offers intense black color that lasts up to 24 hours
• Super easy to remove and suits sensitive eyes
• Waterproof and smudge proof

Pros

• Ophthalmologically tested
• Doesn’t cause dry eyes
• Gives deep black eyes

Cons

• Some may not find it super smudge proof

4. Best in Long-Lasting: SUGAR Kohl of Honour Intense Kajal

Looking for the perfect matte finish in a dashing color? SUGAR Cosmetics has got it for you! The twist up formula of this eyeliner pencil makes it super easy to use and it also glides perfectly on your eyelid or waterline - offering supreme pigment for 12 long hours. It is also completely waterproof and needs no sharpening whatsoever! Just twist, glide and be ready to shine!

What do other eye makeup lovers have to say about it?
Customers like the color of the eyelid color, mentioning it has a slight muted blue tone and has good pigmentation. However, some customers have reported that the value of the product is not worth the money. They also dislike the effect on skin. Customers have mixed opinions on quality, water resistance, smoothness, smudge resistance, and durability.

Why does this waterproof eyeliner pencil deserve to be in your makeup vanity?

• Offers extreme wear being completely waterproof
• Smudge proof and water resistant, keeping look intact for long
• Ergonomically designed in an easy-to-use twist-up form

Pros

• Rich in pigment
• High impact color
• Transfer resistant

Cons

• May not be very long lasting for some

5. Best in Travel: Maybelline New York Eyeliner

Item Form: Gel | Finish Type: Matte | Special Feature: Travel Size, Fade Proof | Product Benefits: Long Lasting | Coverage: Full | Skin Type: All | Weight: 1.2g

Looking for a highly pigmented eyeliner with a tip that lets you get the perfect eyeliner look under seconds? Maybelline has got your back! Making it back to the list we have this brand presented its outstanding eyeliner pencils to the world. This one is ideal for creating a range of looks and suits everyday wear as well.

What do other eye makeup lovers have to say about it?
The ease of application is absolutely sub par! This eyeliner pencil is easy to use and suits perfectly well for beginners. The color is dark and the applicator is super smooth too.

Why does this waterproof eyeliner pencil deserve to be in your makeup vanity?

• Offers an intense finish that adorns you in captivating eye looks
• Easy to use and glide applicator tip that works perfectly every time
• Easy to use and dries off in seconds

Pros

• Easy to use
• Intense color
• Ultra precise lines

Cons

• Some may not find it to be water resistant

FAQs
Does the eyeliner pencil contain any common irritants, such as fragrances or harsh chemicals, that may cause discomfort for sensitive eyes?
A. The eyeliner pencil is specifically formulated without common irritants like fragrances and harsh chemicals. Its hypoallergenic composition ensures gentleness on sensitive eyes, prioritizing comfort. This formulation minimizes the risk of irritation, allowing individuals with sensitive eyes to enjoy long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner without discomfort.

Is liquid or pencil eyeliner better for beginners?
A. For beginners, pencil eyeliner is often easier to control and forgiving during application. Its softer texture allows for more manageable lines, while liquid eyeliner requires a steadier hand. Pencil liners are a great starting point for those learning to create precise lines and experiment with different styles.

How do I sharpen an eyeliner pencil?
To sharpen an eyeliner pencil, use a dedicated cosmetic pencil sharpener. Place the pencil into the sharpener and turn gently, maintaining a slight, consistent pressure. Rotate until you achieve the desired point. Avoid over-sharpening to prevent product wastage and breakage. Clean the sharpener regularly for optimal results.

How to do eyeliner for beginners with pencil?
For pencil eyeliner beginners, start by gently drawing small dashes along the lash line, then connect them for a smooth line. Hold the pencil at a slight angle for better control. Experiment with thickness gradually. Smudge or soften the line with a cotton swab for a more natural look.